Chapter 11 - THE SPEAR
Why did Evelyn throw the decorative spear at Toby?
Her lawyer called it panic.
A terrible split-second act.
No plan.
The spear was part of a hotel display.
Lightweight.
Ceremonial.
Still capable of hurting a child.
Toby had wandered away from the wedding suite and encountered Evelyn in the hallway.
A bridesmaid later remembered hearing Toby say:
“Mommy blue.”
Then Evelyn:
“Stop saying that.”
Toby:
“You took it.”
Then the spear moved.
Evelyn told police she threw it toward the wall to frighten Toby into stopping.
Not at him.
Hotel hallway marks contradicted that.
The spear struck the carpet along Toby’s path.
Thomas had pulled him aside just in time.
Prosecutors considered child-endangerment and assault-related charges separately from Natalie’s death.
That mattered.
Even if the murder case remained difficult, the wedding incident had its own evidence.
Then investigators recovered Evelyn’s wedding-suite phone.
One draft note had been written that morning:
If Toby starts repeating Natalie stories, Thomas must hear that toddlers confuse dreams and memories.
Another:
Do not let him speak to Helen alone.
Thomas felt sick.
Evelyn had anticipated Toby might say something.
Why?
Had Toby accused her before?
The answer came from Toby’s former nanny.
Three months after Natalie died, Toby pointed at a photograph of Evelyn and said:
“Blue gone.”
The nanny told Evelyn.
Evelyn replied:
“He associates Natalie’s medical crisis with everyone who was there.”
Then she asked the nanny not to repeat it to Thomas.
“Why upset him?”
The nanny agreed.
May you like
Another adult had chosen peace over a child’s strange sentence.
And another clue disappeared.
